Capitola Mall entrance with palm trees and a parked car.

The Capitola Mall Went Local Because It's Waiting to Be Rebuilt

"Until construction begins, we have a unique window of opportunity ... to help grow existing businesses or launch new ones, while we cannot commit to long-term leases." That's mall manager Brian Kirk in an email to the Santa Cruz Sentinel last November.

The quote explains the Capitola Mall you walk through today. The game store with the free playroom, the dance studio by the food court, the golf simulator and the children's museum are all there because the mall is waiting to be rebuilt. The owner can't commit to the long-term leases large chain stores want, so it has been renting to local operators on shorter, cheaper terms. In the same article, the Sentinel counted more than 45 local businesses in the building, which is more than half its stores.

This year the city finished its part of the redevelopment, so how long that arrangement lasts now depends on the owner.

How a pending project lowered the rent

The Sentinel describes the deal from both sides. Kirk said the pending redevelopment keeps the owners from offering long-term leases to large chain stores, so the mall takes chances on newer businesses with lower rent.

Sword and Board Games shows how that plays out. Founders Alyssa Lax and Greg Peterson asked mall management about a small kiosk to test the idea. They were offered a full store at a much lower price than anything they'd found elsewhere, and they opened in September 2022, months ahead of their own plan. In 2023 they moved into a larger space in the mall with an adjoining playroom, where customers can borrow board games for free and play in near-daily card tournaments.

Crescendo Dance Academy came for the same reasons. Owner Tanya Treseler told the Sentinel that the affordable rent and easy-to-reach location drew her in. She moved in in August 2025 and teaches ballet, acro, lyrical and jazz to students from ages 2 to 92.

Several owners told the paper they want to stay as long as possible. The Sword and Board founders also said that, as far as they could tell, any real effects of redevelopment were still years away.

What the short-lease years produced

You can see the results in the current Capitola Mall directory. Grouped by what you'd go there for, the local names listed there include:

  • Play and games: Sword and Board Games, Santa Cruz Sports Card, and BetterGolf, whose store page describes a 4,000-square-foot golf simulator.
  • Kids and classes: Crescendo Dance Academy, the Santa Cruz Children's Museum of Discovery, Cirque Tumble Cheer and The Puppetry Institute.
  • Food: Evarista's Comal, Taquizas Gabriel, Bella Fruit and Drink, and Spontaneous Confections. The mall's dining page lists Spontaneous Confections as open Thursday through Saturday, 1 to 6 p.m.
  • Secondhand, books and art: Just Thriftin, Grey Bears Book Den and Art of Santa Cruz.
  • Services: Faust Salon and Matrix Santa Cruz.

Just Thriftin follows the same pattern. It opened in 2024 as an offshoot of a local junk-removal business, Just Junkin, and now restocks mostly through buy-sell-trade with its own customers. The founder told the Sentinel the mall said yes to the idea right away. Spontaneous Confections held a food-court grand opening on Nov. 1, 2025, according to the Sentinel.

Some tenants leave quickly. Orca's Pizza opened in the food court in December 2025 and had closed permanently by late May 2026, the Sentinel reported. The Friends of the Capitola Branch Library Bookstore announced in March that it would close its mall location for good on March 31, 2026, the Sentinel reported.

March 26 finished the city's part

For years the open question was zoning, and that question was settled this spring. The Capitola City Council adopted the mall zoning amendments on March 26, 2026. That followed a unanimous Planning Commission recommendation on Feb. 5 and a first reading on March 16, according to the city's Capitola Mall FAQ.

As the Sentinel summarized it, the new code gives a future developer three options:

  1. Tier 1 is residential only, at up to 48 homes per acre and up to 75 feet in the core.
  2. Tier 2 adds 35,000 square feet of commercial space, a 120-room hotel and 3,600 square feet of meeting space.
  3. Tier 3 allows 200,000 square feet of commercial space with no hotel requirement.

Tiers 2 and 3 allow up to 53 homes per acre and buildings up to 85 feet in the core, and they require 20% affordable housing. The city also made a hotel on the mall block subject to a design permit without a conditional use permit, which the FAQ calls a deliberate incentive.

The 200,000 square feet in Tier 3 is the largest commercial figure in the code, and it's still well below the 339,000 square feet proposed in the 2019 concept. That concept also called for 637 homes, and it never went forward. Lookout Santa Cruz noted that it is not the current project. The city's planning history lists it as withdrawn because of the pandemic. In every scenario, a rebuilt mall has less retail space than the 2019 plan did, and far less than the mall has today.

The housing figures attached to the mall describe capacity in the Housing Element site inventory. The city's FAQ lists 266 low-income, 90 moderate-income and 1,422 market-rate units for the mall block, and none of them belong to an approved project.

The next move is Merlone Geier's

Merlone Geier Partners owns 32 of the 46 acres on the mall block. The city's FAQ says the company had no active redevelopment proposal and took part in the zoning update as a property owner, not as an applicant with a project. The FAQ also says MGP told the city it was waiting for the zoning to be finished before drawing up redevelopment plans.

The zoning is now finished. On its current development projects page, updated in August 2026, MGP says it is "evaluating redevelopment opportunities" at the mall following the city-led rezoning. It adds that any project "would proceed in phases following community outreach and engagement." The same page calls Capitola Mall the only enclosed shopping center in the county, with the nearest competing center 30 miles away.

MGP's statement puts community outreach and engagement ahead of any phased project. The city expects phasing too, because of the size of the property and the need to keep existing businesses accessible. Macy's, Target, Bank of America, Ross and Olive Garden sit on parcels MGP doesn't own, and the city says they would stay open if redevelopment moves ahead.

For the small tenants, the key phrase in Kirk's quote is "until construction begins." By MGP's own account, community outreach comes before any project proceeds, and its August statement describes the company as still evaluating its options.

The city is planning the street around the mall

While the mall waits, the city has kept planning around it. On Oct. 8, the Capitola City Council unanimously adopted the 41st Avenue, Clares Street and Capitola Road Corridor Plan, the Sentinel reported. The plan took more than a year to develop with design firm SWA Group, and a resident survey drew just over 800 responses.

A few details matter to anyone who drives 41st Avenue:

  • The southbound turn lane at 1440 41st Ave. stays. The first draft removed it, but staff warned that would make several businesses much harder to reach.
  • The northbound left-turn lane at 2121 41st Ave. comes out after police reported it was unsafe and prone to accidents.
  • Clares Street gets two recommended midblock pedestrian crossings.

The most-discussed change was on Clares Street. Staff had moved a study of narrowing its lanes to add bike lanes into the plan's appendix after survey pushback. Councilmember Melinda Orbach moved to put the study back in the main plan. She argued that redevelopment along Clares isn't expected soon, partly because Macy's, Olive Garden and Ross belong to other property owners. Waiting to require upgrades until redevelopment happens could take a long time and leave the street improved piecemeal. Her motion passed unanimously.

The plan is a conceptual vision meant to be carried out over time, not a construction schedule, the Sentinel noted before the vote. Down the block, the Planning Commission approved a Tesla sales, service and delivery center in the former Rite Aid at 1475 41st Ave. in King's Plaza on March 5. Lookout reported that it would use just over 21,000 square feet and projected 50 jobs. No opening date has been announced.

Friday at the mall

The mall's local tenants have one of their busiest afternoons this week. Capitola Mall's free Halloween Eve trick-or-treat runs Friday, Oct. 30, from 4 to 6 p.m., with face painting, a photo booth and free treat bags, according to the mall's events page. The same calendar lists Sword and Board Games events through Dec. 31, plus Jazzercise classes and Children's Museum of Discovery programs running through Feb. 28, 2027. The mall is booking the space at least that far ahead.

I've been watching 41st Avenue my whole career, and this is one of the most interesting moments for it in years. If you'd like to talk about what the mall rezoning and the new corridor plan could mean for your corner of Mid-County, reach out to Jessyka Sommers. Let's Connect.

Get Started Today

I am committed to guiding you every step of the way—whether you're buying a home, selling a property, or securing a mortgage. Whatever your needs, I've got you covered.